All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns

A person balances on a slackline between steep cliffs above a forested valleyHello everyone!

Many traders use the Price Action methodology, but do so "by intuition." Since the technique is highly variable, there is a certain advantage in that - the opportunity to develop your own style - but there is also a downside: the absence of rigid rules creates opportunities for self-sabotage and fundamentally incorrect trading with what seems to be a profitable methodology. Today we will try to fix that.

Recently I had the need to comprehensively study the behavior of Price Action patterns, find out how it is still best to trade one setup or another, determine the trading efficiency of each and the change in efficiency depending on the filters used. In other words, I needed to test all the ways of trading each pattern, how best to trade them - with the trend or against it, with pending orders or market orders, what risk-to-reward ratios are best, whether the patterns should be located at a level, what can serve as reliable support and what cannot, and so on.

Agree, such information would be very useful for everyone who uses candlestick patterns in their trading. Since I needed to collect the statistics anyway, I decided to present my findings in the form of an article and share the information with you.

Research Methodology

Research Methodology — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns

I will sequentially test each of the following patterns:

All of these patterns are quite widespread. In general, all Price Action patterns originally come from the Japanese culture of candlestick chart analysis; only the names differ, and sometimes the approaches themselves differ slightly. Therefore, I will give a brief description of the Price Action pattern and the name of its analogue in the Japanese version.

We will conduct the tests on the H1, H4, and D1 periods. We will take the testing period from 2000 to the present day. We will use the following currency pairs: USDCHF, GBPUSD, EURUSD, USDJPY, USDCAD, AUDUSD. These are the main instruments, the most widely traded. If we took all currency pairs for the tests, our research would stretch out for a month - for one pattern alone, with the current set, we would have to conduct more than 500 tests. Speaking of them.

Research Methodology — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns, illustration 2

The first test we will perform to study the predictive ability of the pattern. Here, without setting stops and takes, when a pattern appears we will enter a trade and exit it after a strictly fixed number of candles from the opening of the trade - 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 10, and 12. We will compare the result with the result obtained by flipping a coin. At the same time, we will compare the number of profitable trades, that is, in how many cases the forecast proved correct. It does not matter how far price moved away from the entry point. Thus we will measure the predictive ability of the pattern itself regardless of the system of entries, exits, money management, and position management - pure efficiency compared with completely random entries from coin flips. Let us call it the predictive efficiency test. When conducting this particular test, we will also test various recommendations and rules that strengthen or weaken the pattern. Each results table is for its own pair. The columns mean closes after a certain candle, the rows mean periods. The table contains percentages of profitable trades.

The second test is to determine the best ratio of stops to takes without any additional filtering of entries. Let us call this test the Risk/Reward test. Each results table is for its own pair. The columns mean the stop-to-take-profit ratio, the rows mean periods. At the same time, we will set the number of bars in the history to search for an extreme for stop placement equal to 10. The table contains final deposits. Trading is conducted with a fixed lot of 0.1.

The third test is entry by pattern with filtering by a round level. That is, we will enter trades by pattern only if it rests on a round level. At the same time, we will also try to apply different profit-to-risk ratios. The level test. Each results table is for its own pair. The columns mean the stop-to-take-profit ratio, the rows mean periods. The table contains final deposits. Trading is conducted with a fixed lot of 0.1.

The next test is taking a trade by pattern when price is located relative to a moving average with periods 50, 100, 200. At the same time, we will also try to apply different profit-to-risk ratios. Let us call this the trend test. We will also conduct a test using the position of moving averages in reverse - we will allow sells when price is above the MA and buys when it is below. We will call this test the reverse one. Each results table is for its own pair. The columns mean the stop-to-take-profit ratio, the rows mean periods. The table contains final deposits. Trading is conducted with a fixed lot of 0.1.

Next is the same test, only with filtering by two moving averages with periods 14 and 21 to determine the entry direction. If MA14 is above MA21, only buys are possible. And again we will also try to apply different profit-to-risk ratios. Trend test No. 2. Each results table is for its own pair. The columns mean the stop-to-take-profit ratio, the rows mean periods. The table contains final deposits. Trading is conducted with a fixed lot of 0.1.

The next test is the use of the same moving averages (50, 100, and 200) as support for the pattern. The MA level test (50, 100, 200). Each results table is for its own pair. The columns mean the stop-to-take-profit ratio, the rows mean periods. The table contains final deposits. Trading is conducted with a fixed lot of 0.1.

And the final test is with the use of oscillators: Stochastic, RSI, CCI, WPR. The oscillator test (Stochastic, RSI, CCI, WPR). Each results table is for its own pair. The columns mean the stop-to-take-profit ratio, the rows mean periods. The table contains final deposits. Trading is conducted with a fixed lot of 0.1.

Research Methodology — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns, illustration 3

At the end of each test section, we will draw brief conclusions about the success of applying one trading method or another. After completing all tests for a specific pattern, we will draw general conclusions about the effectiveness of its use and the best ways to trade it. We will also try to combine all the best techniques that we found for trading this pattern. Let us call this the pattern test.

Also, after obtaining the pattern test, we will try to use it to get an exit signal. We will call this the exit test.

And at the end we will put into use all the best things that we managed to find and see what comes of it. We will call this test the combined test.

There is one more point I would like to discuss before running the tests - subjectivity in defining patterns. The thing is that when describing patterns, authors often use adjectives regarding the candles that form the pattern such as large, small, medium. Characteristics such as a candle with almost no body and long tails are also common, for example. The point is that these concepts are alien to a machine; a computer understands only the language of numbers. The algorithm needs specifics to work. In other words: gentlemen, how many grams should we weigh out? This question can be answered in several ways - you can select a specific number of points to determine whether the candle before us is long or not, or you can use such a wonderful indicator as ATR. The ATR indicator measures the average volatility in the market, which is exactly what we need, since volatility changes from market to market and even from day to day. So, ATR shows the average value of volatility, that is, precisely the length of a medium-sized candle in the current market. Therefore, we will assume that:

  • A small candle - from 0 to 0.6 of the ATR value;
  • A medium candle - from 0.6 to 1.4 of the ATR value;
  • A large candle - from 1.4 to 2.5 of the ATR value;
  • A very large candle - from 2.5 to 4 ATR;
  • A huge candle - above 4 ATR.

There is no body on the candle or the body is very small, up to 10% of the length of the whole candle. The same applies to the shadows.

  • A small body (shadow) is up to 30% of the entire candle length;
  • A medium one (body, shadow) is from 30% to 70% of the entire candle length;
  • A full-bodied candle is one where the length of the shadows occupies no more than 30% of the entire candle length.

I think we are done with the basic definitions and can move directly to the tests themselves.

Doji Patterns

Doji Patterns — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns

A doji is a candle in which the opening and closing prices are equal, or almost equal. There should also be shadows on both sides of the candle, of approximately the same size.

Before the doji candle, there should be a full-bodied candle of medium or large size in the direction of the trend. It is this candle that determines the nature of the doji.

When trading a doji, you should wait for confirmation, that is, one more candle should appear after the doji appears. If the last candle closes in the direction of the preceding trend, we get the Price Action pattern "Move - Congestion - Move" or "Movement - Consolidation - Movement", a trend continuation pattern. If the last candle is against the established trend, we have a Price Point Reversal pattern or a "Reversal Point". In the Japanese version, the pattern is called the "Morning or Evening Doji Star". Exactly the same pattern, but simply with a small candle instead of a doji, is called simply the "Morning or Evening Star". If a gap occurred between the doji and the candles surrounding it, then such a pattern turns into an "Abandoned Baby" pattern. Since gaps are a rare occurrence in the forex market, we will not single out this pattern separately.

As for the doji candle itself, it comes in three varieties:

  • A doji star has a very small body (up to 10%) or no body at all, while the size of the candle itself is small (up to 0.6 ATR);
  • The second variety is the gravestone doji, which strongly resembles a pin bar, only with practically no body;
  • The third variety is the rickshaw doji. This candle has a small body located approximately in the middle of the candle and fairly large shadows in both directions of roughly the same size.

Also, when talking about a doji candle, they often mean a small candle (up to 0.6 ATR) with a small body (up to 30% of the length of the entire candle). Let us call this candle, within the framework of this study, a non-strict doji.

Now let us determine the frequency of occurrence of such a pattern on charts of different currencies and different periods. Here we will not use any filters or confirmations. We will simply check the very fact of the appearance of a medium or long full-bodied candle with a doji candle of one of four types.

Table of doji pattern frequencies across six currency pairs and H1, H4, and D1 timeframesAs you can see, the frequency of occurrence of the pattern on daily charts is quite low. Nevertheless, on H4 and H1 periods the pattern appears quite often.

Price Point Reversal

Price Point Reversal — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns

The first tests that we will conduct will be on the Price Point Reversal pattern or the "Reversal Point". The Japanese analogue is the "Morning or Evening Star". We will enter fully according to the rules of the pattern, with pending orders placed 5 points from the High/Low of the signal (confirming) candle. The predictive efficiency test is done without Stoploss and Takeprofit orders; for the remaining tests, the stop is set at the ten-bar extremum. That is, on the nearest 10 candles the lowest point for buys or the highest for sells is found, an offset of 5 old points is taken from this point, and the stop is set at the resulting level. Takeprofit is calculated as a ratio to the size of the stop in points: 1 to 1, 1 to 2, 1 to 3, and so on. Since we will be entering with pending orders, it is necessary to clarify the rule for deleting orders if they are not triggered. I will take the generally accepted version: if the order is not activated within 5 candles, it is deleted.

Predictive Efficiency Test

Here we will check the predictive efficiency of the pattern, that is, how likely a movement in the right direction is after a certain number of candles following the appearance of the pattern.

Doji Star

Table of forex reversal pattern statistics, with performance figures highlighted in green and yellowGravestone Doji

Green and yellow trading statistics table showing currency pairs and price action pattern resultsRickshaw Doji

Color-coded table comparing price action reversal pattern statistics across currency pairsNon-strict doji

Color-coded table of Price Point Reversal pattern statistics across currency pairs and timeframesSummary Table

Summary table of Price Point Reversal trading results with green and yellow cells across currency pairsAs can be seen from the results, there is no strong difference in which type of doji candle is used as a pattern. On some instruments the doji star works a little better, on others the gravestone doji, and so on. Therefore, in further tests we will combine all types of doji candles into one. In addition, you can see that on average the appearing pattern allows you to predict the price with a probability of about 45%. So how can you make money on such a pattern when we are wrong more often than we are right? The secret lies in the correct profit-to-risk ratio, which will be discussed further.

Risk/Reward Test

Price Point Reversal — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns, illustration 2

Color-coded risk/reward test tables for Price Point Reversal trades across currency pairsBased on the summary table, we can conclude that the classic 1 to 3 ratio is not suitable for all instruments. If you look at the average values across all pairs, you can see that the 1 to 2, 1 to 3, and 1 to 6 ratios perform best. Nevertheless, the larger the ratio, the fewer profitable trades you will have and the longer the drawdown periods will be. In addition, each pair should have its own profit-to-risk ratio selected, because, for example, for USDCHF it is optimal to use a 1 to 5 ratio, whereas for EURUSD this ratio is the worst possible. In addition, this ratio also differs for different periods. While for TF D1, 1 to 3 is mostly optimal, for H4 it is better to choose 1 to 2, and for H1, 1 to 5 or higher.

Price Point Reversal — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns, illustration 3

Round Levels Test

Green and yellow tables compare Price Point Reversal backtest results across forex pairs and risk-reward ratiosTest at the MA 50 level

Color-coded tables of Price Point Reversal test results at the 50-period moving average across currency pairsTest at the MA 100 level

Color-coded tables of Price Point Reversal test results for currency pairs at the 100-period moving averageTest at the MA 200 level

Color-coded tables of forex Price Point Reversal test results at the 200-period moving averageTests by levels - summary table

Summary table of Price Point Reversal backtests across currency pairs, timeframes and moving average levelsAs can be seen from the table, the pattern with support from a level gives a much better effect, and it is not so important what is used as the level. And again, on different instruments the effectiveness of one or another type of level differs. For example, round levels are well respected on daily charts on practically all currency pairs, but on lower periods they are not respected at all. Using a moving average with a period of 50 as a level may be a good idea for the daily charts of USDCHF and GBPUSD and a very bad one for the USDCAD pair. At the same time, on average, MA100 proved itself best as a level. But on the USDJPY pair, levels work poorly in general. In general, once again there is no universal option here and everything should depend on the character of a specific currency pair. But we have made sure that a pattern resting on a level works better in most cases.

Test by MA50 trend

Price Point Reversal — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns, illustration 4

Green and yellow tables compare Price Point Reversal test results across currency pairs using an MA50 trend filterTest by MA50 trend (reversal)

Color-coded tables of Price Point Reversal backtest results filtered by the MA50 trend across currency pairsTest by MA100 trend

Color-coded tables of Price Point Reversal backtest results for currency pairs filtered by the MA100 trendTest by MA100 trend (reversal)

Color-coded tables of forex Price Point Reversal backtest results filtered by the MA100 trendTest by MA200 trend

Color-coded tables of Price Point Reversal test results for currency pairs, filtered by the MA200 trendTest by MA200 trend (reversal)

Green and yellow tables of Price Point Reversal backtest results for currency pairs, filtered by the MA200 trendTest by trend No. 2

Color-coded tables of Price Point Reversal test results by currency pair and timeframe for trend No. 2Tests by trend - summary table

Color-coded summary table of Price Point Reversal trend test results across currency pairs and timeframesAs can be seen from the table, the best indicator of the presence of a trend is the good old rule: when the price is above the moving average, the trend is up, and when it is below, the trend is down. At the same time, it is best to use moving average periods of 100 and 200. At the same time, this approach works best precisely on daily charts. Despite the fact that once again we observe individual preferences for each pair and period, in general it can be said that working with patterns along the trend really improves the initial result.

Test by the Stochastic oscillator

Price Point Reversal — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns, illustration 5

Green and yellow tables of Stochastic oscillator test results for Price Point Reversal patterns across forex pairsTest by the CCI oscillator

Color-coded tables of CCI oscillator test results for Price Point Reversal patterns across currency pairsTest by the WPR oscillator

WPR oscillator test results for currency pairs across timeframes, with green and yellow highlighted table cellsTests by oscillators - summary table

Color-coded tables summarize oscillator tests for Price Point Reversal patterns across currency pairs and timeframesThe use of oscillator readings as a filter undoubtedly improves the results. At the same time, the Stochastic Oscillator shows itself best in this role.

Pattern test

Price Point Reversal — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns, illustration 6

This is what pattern trading looks like on the H1 period for the currency pairs we are considering:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for H1 currency trading using the Price Point Reversal patternIf we replace the standard stop by the candle shadow with a stop by the ATR indicator, we get the following result:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for the Price Point Reversal strategy using ATR-based stopsYou can also add a trailing stop by candle shadows to the trading system - we will pull our initial stop loss after the price by the candle shadows:

Trading strategy test report with an equity curve rising from about 10,000 to 30,000, interrupted by drawdownsAnd here is what will happen if you use the opposite signal to exit the position:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for a Price Point Reversal strategy using opposite signals to exit tradesAs can be seen from the tests, the best signal is achieved when setting the stop loss at a level of 2-4 ATR from the entry price and using an "entered and forgot" strategy. Both the use of a trail and the condition of exiting on the reverse signal only spoiled our statistics.

Now let's take a look at trading on the H4 period:

H4 backtest report with an equity curve rising from about 10,000 to 23,000 before a slight declineThere are noticeably fewer entries, only 25% of the trades are profitable, but we still make money by placing stops according to the classic rule, below or above the candle shadow. Although the drawdown periods are quite long, the average winning trade is four times larger than the average loss. Let's apply 2-4 ATR stops:

Backtest report for Price Point Reversal showing a rising equity curve with extended drawdownsOur drawdown increased, the average profit is now less than twice the loss, but almost half of the trades are profitable. The expectancy increased and the profit tripled. Let's add a trailing stop:

Backtest report with an upward equity curve and drawdowns for the Price Point Reversal trading strategyHere the data is very similar to the previous one, except that the profit factor rose from 1.4 to 1.55 and the balance curve became smoother. Now let's add an exit-on-opposite-signal condition:

Strategy backtest report with a steadily rising balance curve and a profit factor of 1.55This condition slightly reduced the profit factor and the final profit, but sharply cut the drawdown from 28% to only 6%.

Conclusions

Price Point Reversal — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns, illustration 7

We found that there is no strong difference in which type of doji candle is used in this pattern. On some instruments the doji star works a little better, on others the gravestone doji, and so on. In addition, the classic 1 to 3 ratio is not suitable for all instruments. The optimal profit-to-loss ratio in this pattern varies from 1 to 2 to 1 to 6 depending on the instrument and the period. At the same time, both using levels and trading with the trend improve trading results. It is best to use the good old MA100 both as a level and as a trend indicator. And the best oscillator for filtering signals turned out to be Stochastic. As can be seen from the summary tests carried out, the pattern really works, the methods of filtering the signal by trend, by levels, and by oscillators also work, however each currency pair and each timeframe requires its own approach. As for trade management, it is clearly visible that a trailing stop based on candle shadows works well only on periods from H4 and above. Exiting on the opposite signal also proved effective on the H4 period and higher. But placing stop-loss orders below or above the candle shadow turned out to be ineffective. The ATR indicator multiplied by a factor from 2 to 4 is much better suited for determining the stop level.

Price Point Reversal — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns, illustration 8

The Price Action Pattern "Move - Congestion - Move" or "Movement - Consolidation - Movement"

Frequency of occurrence of the MCM pattern

Tables showing MCM pattern frequency across six forex pairs on H1, H4 and D1, split by pattern directionAs you can see, the pattern does not appear very often even on the H4 period.

Predictive effectiveness test

Doji star

Color-coded trading statistics table comparing currency pairs across timeframes for price action patternsGravestone doji

Trading results table with green and yellow cells showing performance metrics across currency pairsRickshaw doji

Green and yellow trading statistics table comparing results across currency pairs and timeframesLoose doji

Color-coded table of trading statistics with highlighted values for price action pattern comparisonsSummary table

Summary table of Move–Congestion–Move price action results across currency pairs, with green and yellow cellsAs can be seen from the results, there is no strong difference in which type of doji candle is used in the pattern. On some instruments the doji star works a little better, on others the gravestone doji, and so on. Therefore, in further tests we will combine all types of doji candles into one. In addition, you can see that on average the pattern that appears allows you to predict price with a probability of about 45%. So how can you make money on such a pattern when we are wrong more often than we are right? The secret lies in the correct profit-to-risk ratio, which will be discussed below.

Risk/Reward test

The Price Action Pattern "Move - Congestion - Move" or "Movement - Consolidation - Movement" — All the Secrets of Price

Risk/reward test table for the Move–Congestion–Move pattern, with color-coded results across currency pairsBased on the summary table, we can conclude that the classic 1 to 3 ratio is not suitable for all instruments. If you look at the average values across all pairs, you can see that the ratios 1 to 2, 1 to 3, and 1 to 6 perform best. Nevertheless, the larger the ratio, the fewer profitable trades you will have and the longer the drawdown periods will be. In addition, each pair should have its own profit-to-risk ratio selected.

Round levels test

The Price Action Pattern "Move - Congestion - Move" or "Movement - Consolidation - Movement" — All the, illustration 2

Green and yellow tables compare Move–Congestion–Move pattern test results across forex pairs and timeframesMA 50 level test

Green-shaded table of currency pairs and numeric readings across timeframes for an MA 50 level testMA 100 level test

Color-coded tables compare trading results for the Move–Congestion–Move pattern with an MA 100 level testMA 200 level test

Green and yellow table of Move–Congestion–Move pattern results across currency pairs and timeframes, with MA 200 testsLevel tests - summary table

Color-coded summary table of level tests for the Move–Congestion–Move Price Action pattern across currency pairsAs can be seen from the table, the pattern based on a level gives a better effect, and it is not so important what is used as the level. And again, on different instruments the effectiveness of one type of level or another differs. For example, pairs such as USDJPY and USDCAD do not particularly respect any levels at all. At the same time, MA200 performed best on USDCHF and EURUSD, while MA100 on GBPUSD and AUDUSD. From this we can conclude that if you are going to use a moving average as a dynamic level, its period should be selected for the specific market.

Trend Test MA50

The Price Action Pattern "Move - Congestion - Move" or "Movement - Consolidation - Movement" — All the, illustration 3

Color-coded MA50 trend test tables for currency pairs across timeframes, with green and yellow performance cellsTrend Test MA50 (reverse)

Color-coded table of MA50 reverse trend test results for the Move–Congestion–Move price action patternTrend Test MA100

Trend Test MA100 table with green and yellow cells comparing currency pairs across multiple timeframesTrend Test MA100 (reverse)

Green and yellow tables show MA100 reverse trend test results for multiple forex pairs and parameter settingsTrend Test MA200

Color-coded table of MA200 trend test results for currency pairs across multiple timeframesTrend Test MA200 (reverse)

Green-shaded table of currency-pair results for the MA200 reverse trend test of the move-consolidation-move patternTrend Test No. 2

Color-coded tables of forex results for the Move–Congestion–Move Price Action pattern across currency pairsTrend Tests - Summary Table

Color-coded summary table of trend tests for the Move–Congestion–Move price action patternAnd again, the best indicator of the presence of a trend is the position of price relative to the moving average. At the same time, it is best to use moving average periods of 100 and 200. Despite the fact that we again observe individual preferences for each pair and period, in general we can say that working with patterns in the direction of the trend really improves the final result.

Oscillator tests are not conducted, since this pattern is a trend one.

Pattern Test

The Price Action Pattern "Move - Congestion - Move" or "Movement - Consolidation - Movement" — All the, illustration 4

This is what trading the pattern on the H1 period looks like for the currency pairs we are considering:

H1 backtest report for the Move–Congestion–Move pattern, with an equity curve rising from about 10,000 to 35,000If we replace the standard stop by the candle shadow with a stop based on the ATR indicator, we get the following result:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve showing results of using ATR-based stops for the Move–Congestion–Move patternWe can also add a trailing stop by candle shadows to the trading system - we will trail our initial stop loss behind the price by the candle shadows:

Strategy backtest report with a rising equity curve and trading performance statisticsAnd here is what happens if we use the opposite signal to exit the position:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for a Move–Congestion–Move strategy using opposite signals to exit tradesAs can be seen from the tests, the best signal is achieved when setting a stop loss at the level of 2-4 ATR from the entry price and using the set-and-forget strategy. Both the use of a trailing stop and the exit condition based on the reverse signal only spoiled our statistics.

Now let us look at trading on the H4 period:

H4 trading backtest report with an equity curve rising from about 10,000 to 40,000 before a final dipLet us apply 2-4 ATR stops:

Trading backtest report with a rising equity curve for the Move–Congestion–Move pattern using 2–4 ATR stopsLet us add a trailing stop:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve after adding a trailing stop to the Move–Congestion–Move strategyNow let us add an exit condition based on the opposite signal:

Strategy backtest report with a rising equity curve and trade statistics after adding an opposite-signal exitThe best option again is when applying an ATR-based stop without interfering with the course of the trade.

Conclusions

The Price Action Pattern "Move - Congestion - Move" or "Movement - Consolidation - Movement" — All the, illustration 5

We found out that there is no strong difference in which type of doji candle is used in this pattern. On some instruments the doji star works a little better, on others the gravestone doji, and so on. In addition, the classic 1 to 3 ratio is not suitable for all instruments. The optimal profit-to-loss ratio in this pattern varies from 1 to 2 to 1 to 6 depending on the instrument and period. At the same time, both relying on levels and trading with the trend improve trading results. It is best to use the good old MA100 both as a level and as a trend indicator. And the best oscillator for filtering signals turned out to be Stochastic. As can be seen from the summary tests carried out, the pattern really works, the methods of filtering the signal by trend, by levels, and by oscillators also work, however, each currency pair and each timeframe requires its own approach. As for trade management, it is clearly visible that a trailing stop by candle shadows works well only on periods from H4 and above. Exiting on the opposite signal also proved effective on the H4 period and above. But placing stop loss orders below or above the candle shadow turned out to be ineffective. The ATR indicator multiplied by a coefficient from 2 to 4 is much better suited for determining the stop level.

Price Action Inside Bar Pattern in Trend

Price Action Inside Bar Pattern in Trend — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns

Frequency of occurrence of the IB pattern

Table of inside bar pattern frequency across six currency pairs on H1, H4 and daily timeframesAs can be seen, this pattern is a fairly frequent occurrence even on daily charts.

Predictive efficiency test

Table of predictive efficiency test results for the Inside Bar pattern across currency pairs, shaded green and yellowOn the H4 period and above, the price direction determined by the appearance of the pattern is slightly better than a coin toss.

Risk/Reward test

Risk/reward test tables for the inside bar pattern across currency pairs, with green and yellow performance cellsProfit-to-loss ratios from 1 to 3 and higher perform better.

Round levels test

Tables comparing forex inside bar trading results across risk-reward ratios, with green and yellow cellsMA 50 level test

Color-coded table compares inside bar trading results across currency pairs, timeframes and moving average settingsMA 100 level test

Green and yellow tables compare currency pair trading results across risk-to-reward ratiosMA 200 level test

Color-coded table of currency pairs across timeframes showing price distances from the 200-period moving averageTests by levels, summary table

Color-coded summary tables of inside bar pattern test results across currency pairs, timeframes and moving averagesFrom the summary table it is clear that it would be optimal to use MA100 and MA200 as the level.

MA50 trend test

Color-coded table of MA50 trend test results for currency pairs across multiple risk-to-reward ratiosMA50 trend test (reversal)

Color-coded tables compare inside bar trading results across currency pairs and timeframes in an MA50 trend testMA100 trend test

Green-shaded tables of forex inside bar strategy test results using an MA100 trend filterMA100 trend test (reversal)

Green and yellow tables of MA100 trend reversal test results for currency pairs across multiple timeframesMA200 trend test

Green-shaded tables of MA200 trend test results for currency pairs across different timeframesMA200 trend test (reversal)

Color-coded tables of MA200 trend reversal test results for currency pairs across timeframes and risk-reward ratiosTrend test No. 2

Color-coded tables of inside bar trend test results across currency pairs and timeframesTrend tests, summary table

Color-coded tables summarize inside bar trend test results across currency pairs and timeframesIn most cases, taking the trend direction into account in trading improves the final result.

Pattern test

Price Action Inside Bar Pattern in Trend — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns, illustration 2

This is what trading the pattern on the H1 period looks like on the currency pairs we are considering:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for H1 inside bar trend trading across multiple currency pairsIf we replace the standard stop by the candle shadow with a stop by the ATR indicator, we will get the following result:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for a trend inside bar strategy using ATR-based stopsYou can also add a trailing stop by candle shadows to the trading system: we will pull our initial stop loss behind the price by the candle shadows:

Trading backtest report with a rising equity curve and performance statistics for an inside bar trend strategyAnd here is what happens if you use the opposite signal to exit the position:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for a trend inside bar strategy using opposite signals to exit tradesAs tests show, the best signal is achieved when the stop-loss is set at 2-4 ATR from the entry price and with a "set and forget" strategy. Both the use of a trailing stop and the exit condition on the opposite signal only worsened our statistics.

Now let us look at trading on the H4 period:

H4 inside bar strategy backtest report with a rising blue equity curve and trading performance statisticsLet us apply 2-4 ATR stops:

Backtest statistics and a rising equity curve for an inside bar strategy using 2–4 ATR stopsLet us add a trailing stop:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for an inside bar trend strategy using a trailing stopNow let us add an exit condition based on the opposite signal:

Trading backtest report with a rising equity curve for a trend-following inside bar strategy using opposite-signal exitsIt is clear that this time the trailing stop and the exit on the opposite signal improved our trading.

Conclusions

Price Action Inside Bar Pattern in Trend — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns, illustration 3

For the inside bar pattern, as for all the previous ones, all the classic advice remains true - trade with the trend, look for levels, and keep the risk-to-reward ratio above 1 to 2.

Price Action Inside Bar Pattern Against the Trend

IB pattern occurrence frequency

Table of countertrend Inside Bar pattern frequencies across six currency pairs on H1, H4 and D1 timeframesThe pattern appears quite often

Predictive efficiency test

Color-coded table of predictive efficiency test results for the Price Action inside bar pattern against the trendEven hourly timeframes for this pattern show results that are fairly better than a coin toss.

Risk/Reward test

Risk/reward test table for countertrend inside bar trades across currency pairs on H1, H4, and daily timeframesEverything is as usual here. Only the GBPUSD pair was surprising, showing the best results with a profit-to-risk ratio of 1 to 1.

Round levels test

Green and yellow tables compare currency pair trading results across risk-to-reward ratios from 1:1 to 1:6MA 50 level test

Stacked color-coded tables of currency pair trading results across multiple timeframesMA 100 level test

Color-coded tables compare forex inside bar trading results across risk-reward ratios using the MA 100 filterMA 200 level test

Color-coded tables of Inside Bar trading results for currency pairs using a 200-period moving average filterLevel tests - summary table

Color-coded tables summarize trading results for inside bar patterns against the trend across currency pairs and timeframesNot all pairs respect levels, but in general the best ones are MA100 and MA200. Traditionally, the yen and the Canadian dollar ignore levels.

MA50 trend test

MA50 trend test results for forex pairs across timeframes, shown in green and yellow tablesMA50 trend test (reverse)

Green and yellow tables compare inside bar trading results against the trend using an MA50 filterMA100 trend test

Color-coded tables compare Inside Bar trading results across currency pairs and timeframes in an MA100 trend testMA100 trend test (reverse)

Color-coded tables compare inside bar trading results against the MA100 trend across currency pairs and timeframesTrend Test MA200

Color-coded tables of inside bar trading results across currency pairs using an MA200 trend filterTrend Test MA200 (reversal)

Color-coded tables of inside bar reversal backtest results against the MA200 trend across currency pairsTrend Test No. 2

Green and yellow tables compare forex pair results for Trend Test No. 2 of the countertrend inside bar patternTrend Tests - summary table

Color-coded summary tables of inside bar trading tests against the trend across currency pairs and timeframesThis table once again proves to us that any level is better than no level at all.

Stochastic oscillator test

Color-coded tables of stochastic oscillator test results for currency pairs across multiple timeframesCCI oscillator test

Stacked green and yellow tables showing CCI oscillator test results for inside bar trades against the trendRSI oscillator test

Color-coded tables compare RSI test results for countertrend inside bar trades across currency pairs and timeframesOscillator tests - summary table

Green-shaded summary table of oscillator test results for countertrend inside bar trades across currency pairsPattern test

Price Action Inside Bar Pattern Against the Trend — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns

This is what trading the pattern on the H1 period looks like on the currency pairs we are considering:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for H1 countertrend inside bar trading across currency pairsIf you replace the standard stop by the candle shadow with a stop based on the ATR indicator, you get the following result:

Backtest report with an equity curve rising from 10,000 to 13,500 for an inside bar strategy using ATR-based stopsYou can also add a trailing stop based on candle shadows to the trading system - we will pull our initial stop loss along behind the price using the candle shadows:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for an inside bar strategy using a candle-shadow trailing stopAnd here is what happens if you use the opposite signal to exit the position:

Trading backtest report with a rising equity curve for an inside bar strategy using opposite signals to exit tradesThis time, the use of an ATR stop, trailing stop, and exit improved the quality of trading.

Now let's look at trading on the H4 period:

H4 inside bar strategy backtest report with a steadily rising balance curve and trading performance statisticsLet's apply stops of 2-4 ATR:

Strategy backtest report with a rising blue equity curve for countertrend inside bars using 2–4 ATR stopsLet's add a trailing stop:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for an inside bar strategy using a trailing stopNow let's add an exit condition on the reverse signal:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for an inside bar strategy using reverse signals to exit tradesThis time, the best results came from applying the standard approach. Both the ATR stop, the trailing stop, and the exit on the reverse signal only worsened the result.

Conclusions

Price Action Inside Bar Pattern Against the Trend — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns, illustration 2

Once again, we have become convinced of the steadfastness of the main recommendations when trading candlestick patterns. Overall, the inside bar pattern gives quite good results.

Price Action Outside Bar Pattern

Frequency of occurrence of the OB pattern

Table of Outside Bar pattern frequencies for six currency pairs on H1, H4 and D1 timeframesThe OB pattern is a fairly common occurrence on any timeframe.

Predictive effectiveness test

Table of outside bar pattern predictive effectiveness test results, with green and yellow highlighted cellsThe pattern's effectiveness at predicting the future price direction is slightly worse than a coin toss.

Risk/Reward test

Color-coded tables compare outside bar trading results across currency pairs and risk-to-reward ratiosIt is best to use a profit-to-loss ratio of at least 1 to 3 for the OB pattern.

Round levels test

Color-coded tables of currency pair test results at round price levels for the Outside Bar patternTest at the MA 50 level

Color-coded tables compare outside bar pattern test results at the MA 50 level across currency pairs and timeframesTest at the MA 100 level

Color-coded tables of Outside Bar pattern test results at the MA 100 level across currency pairsTest at the MA 200 level

Color-coded tables of trading test results for currency pairs at the 200-period moving averageLevel tests - summary table

Color-coded summary tables of level test results for the Price Action Outside Bar patternAny type of level for this pattern turned out to be a fairly effective filter.

MA50 trend test

Green and yellow tables compare outside bar trading test results across currency pairs using an MA50 trend filterMA50 trend test (reversal)

Color-coded tables of MA50 reversal test results across currency pairs and timeframes for the outside bar patternMA100 trend test

Color-coded tables of Outside Bar trading test results for currency pairs using an MA100 trend filterMA100 trend test (reversal)

Color-coded table of MA100 trend reversal test results across currency pairs and risk-to-reward ratiosMA200 trend test

Color-coded tables of MA200 trend test results for currency pairs across multiple risk-to-reward ratiosMA200 trend test (reversal)

Green and yellow tables show MA200 trend reversal test results across currency pairs and timeframesTrend test No. 2

Green and yellow table comparing outside bar trend test results across currency pairs and timeframesTrend tests - summary table

Color-coded table summarizing outside bar trend test results across currency pairs and moving averagesThe OB pattern should definitely be taken in the direction of the main trend.

Pattern test

Price Action Outside Bar Pattern — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns

This is what trading the pattern looks like on the H1 period on the currency pairs we are considering:

Strategy Tester report with a rising equity curve for an H1 Outside Bar Price Action strategy on currency pairsIf we replace the standard stop at the candle shadow with an ATR-based stop, we get the following result:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for the Outside Bar strategy using ATR-based stopsYou can also add a trailing stop by candle shadows to the trading system - we will pull our initial stop-loss after the price by the candle wicks:

Trading strategy backtest report with a rising equity curve and performance statisticsAnd here is what happens if you use the opposite signal to exit the position:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for an outside bar strategy using opposite signals to exit tradesOn hourly charts, the OB pattern works best with a trailing stop and a stop-loss set according to ATR readings.

Now let's look at trading on the H4 period:

H4 outside bar strategy backtest report with a rising equity curve and trading performance statisticsLet's apply stops of 2-4 ATR:

Backtest report and rising equity curve for an Outside Bar Price Action strategy using stops of 2–4 ATRLet's add a trailing stop:

Strategy tester report with a rising equity curve showing Outside Bar trading results with a trailing stopNow let's add an exit condition on an opposite signal:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for an Outside Bar strategy using opposite signals to exit trades, illustration 2The same applies to the H4 period - the best result comes from using a trailing stop and an ATR stop.

Conclusions

The Outside Bar pattern performs quite well on any period, especially if, when trading it, active management of the open position is applied.

Price Action Outside Bar Pattern — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns, illustration 2

Price Action Pin Bar Pattern

Frequency of the Pinbar pattern appearance

Table of Pin Bar pattern frequency across six currency pairs on H1, H4, and D1 timeframesA good pinbar appears on the chart a little less often than OB, and yet it is one of the most frequently occurring PA patterns.

Predictive effectiveness test

Table of pin bar predictive effectiveness across currency pairs and timeframes, with results shaded green and yellowOn average, the predictive effectiveness of the pinbar pattern is no better than a simple coin toss.

Risk/Reward test

Color-coded tables compare pin bar risk/reward test results for currency pairs at ratios from 1:1 to 1:6Based on the information in the table, once again an effective Risk/Reward should be no less than 3 to 1.

Round levels test

Color-coded tables of round-level test results for currency pairs across multiple timeframesMA 50 level test

Color-coded tables compare pin bar trading results across currency pairs and moving average levels, including MA 50MA 100 level test

Green and yellow tables compare currency pair results for Price Action pin bar tests at the MA 100 levelMA 200 level test

Color-coded tables of pin bar test results at the 200-period moving average across currency pairsLevel tests - summary table

Color-coded tables summarize price action pin bar level tests across currency pairs and moving averagesThe pinbar pattern is perfectly complemented by dynamic levels in the form of MA100 and MA200. And round levels are not so bad either.

MA50 trend test

Color-coded tables of forex trading results for a pin bar strategy tested with an MA50 trend filterMA50 trend test (reversal)

Green and yellow tables of trading test results for currency pairs using the MA50 trend reversal strategyMA100 trend test

Green and yellow tables compare pin bar trading test results across currency pairs using an MA100 trend filterMA100 trend test (reversal)

Green-shaded tables show MA100 trend test results for pin bar reversals across currency pairs and timeframesMA200 trend test

Color-coded tables of MA200 trend test results for pin bar trades across currency pairs and timeframesMA200 trend test (reversal)

Table of MA200 trend reversal pin bar test results for forex pairs across risk-to-reward ratiosTrend test No. 2

Color-coded trading results table for trend test No. 2 of the Price Action pin bar pattern across currency pairsTrend tests summary table

Green and yellow summary table comparing pin bar trend test results across currency pairs and timeframesWhichever moving average you choose to determine the trend, it will still be better than not paying attention to the direction of price at all.

Stochastic oscillator test

Color-coded tables comparing pin bar trading results across currency pairs and stochastic oscillator settingsCCI oscillator test

CCI oscillator backtest results for pin bar patterns, shown in green and yellow tables by currency pairWPR oscillator test

Green and yellow tables compare trading test results across currency pairs and risk-to-reward ratiosOscillator tests summary table

Oscillator test summary tables for currency pairs, with trading results highlighted in green and yellowAny of the oscillators can in some cases worsen the final result, but more often it still helps. The only condition is the individual selection of settings for each currency and period.

Pattern test

Price Action Pin Bar Pattern — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns

This is what pattern trading looks like on the H1 period for the currency pairs we are considering:

H1 pin bar strategy backtest report with a rising equity curve from about 10,000 to 12,000If we replace the standard stop at the candle shadow with an ATR-based stop, we get the following result:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for a Price Action pin bar strategy using an ATR-based stopWe can also add a trailing stop by candle shadows to the trading system; we will move our initial stop loss after the price along the candle shadows:

Strategy tester report with a rising equity curve for a pin bar trading system using a trailing stopAnd here is what will happen if we use the opposite signal to exit the position:

Backtest report with an upward-trending equity curve for a pin bar strategy using opposite signals to exit tradesWhen trading the pinbar on the H1 period, none of our improvements proved effective.

Now let us look at trading on the H4 period:

H4 pin bar strategy backtest report with a rising equity curve and trading performance statisticsLet us apply 2-4 ATR stops:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for a Price Action pin bar strategy using 2–4 ATR stopsLet us add a trailing stop:

Backtest report with a steadily rising equity curve for a pin bar strategy using a trailing stopNow let us add an exit condition based on the opposite signal:

Trading backtest report with a rising equity curve after adding an exit condition based on an opposite pin bar signalUnlike the H1 period, here any of our improvements leads to a more interesting result.

Conclusions

Price Action Pin Bar Pattern — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns, illustration 2

The pinbar pattern, despite its prevalence and broadest fame, does not lose its relevance and profitability. Which is surprising, because a huge number of traders trade pinbars. But as we can see, this does not make things worse for anyone.

Testing all patterns together

This is what trading patterns on the H1 period looks like for the currency pairs we are considering:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for combined H1 price action patterns across multiple currency pairsIf we replace the standard stop at the candle shadow with an ATR-based stop, we get the following result:

Backtest report for combined Price Action patterns with ATR-based stops shows a steadily rising equity curveYou can also add a trailing stop based on candle shadows to the trading system - we will pull our initial stop loss along behind the price using the candle shadows:

Backtest report with a rising blue equity curve for a trading system combining Price Action patternsAnd here is what will happen if you use the opposite signal to exit the position:

Backtest report with an upward equity curve for all price action patterns, using opposite signals to exit tradesOn the H1 timeframe, trading all the PA patterns discussed in the article produced a fairly pleasant-looking equity curve. At the same time, more than 10000 trades over 17 years tell us that you will not have to be bored with this kind of trading - at least 2 trades a day should be possible.

Now let's look at trading on the H4 timeframe:

H4 Price Action backtest report with a steadily rising balance curve and trading performance statisticsLet's apply stops of 2-4 ATR:

Backtest report for combined Price Action patterns with 2–4 ATR stops, showing a steadily rising equity curveLet's add a trailing stop:

Backtest report with a rising equity curve for combined Price Action patterns using a trailing stopNow let's add an exit condition based on the opposite signal:

Backtest report for combined Price Action patterns, with a steadily rising equity curve and a small late drawdownThe best option when trading on H4 is to use ATR-based stops together with active position management. The number of trades is not much lower than when trading on H1. But the strain on your nerves is far lower.

Conclusion

Conclusion — All the Secrets of Price Action Patterns

In this article, we examined the application of the main and most common PA patterns and once again confirmed the following things in practice:

  • Candlestick patterns should be traded from levels;
  • It is highly desirable to take trades in the direction of the main trend;
  • The reward-to-risk ratio should be at least 1 to 3.

In addition, we now know that:

  • Every rule has its exceptions, and for the most effective trading you need to know the instrument you trade well - there are pairs that ignore levels, and there are those on which a given pattern simply does not work;
  • 30-40% winning trades is normal, and if you do everything correctly and follow money management, your account will grow;
  • Trading drawdowns are an inevitable part of trading, especially candlestick-pattern trading.

It is believed that when trading Price Action you need to use your head. Today we made sure that even mechanical adherence to mechanical trading rules leads to a quite good result. Of course, this does not mean that you should not use your head. It means that if it joins your trading as well, the results will be much more interesting.

Price Action Thread on the Forum

Respectfully, Dmitry aka Silentspec TradeLikeaPro.ru

Forex VPS - Reliable VPS for the forex market