Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend?

Kim Jong Un smiles while holding an apple in an orchard, surrounded by officialsGreetings to you, fellow forex traders!

A question that sooner or later begins to trouble everyone who trades on the D1 and H4 timeframes. The arguments about whether it is worth leaving open positions over the weekend have not died down for a long time. Traders have split into two opposite camps - some believe that you need to strictly follow the rules of the system and close positions only when the TS indicates it, while others are afraid to carry orders over because of possible gaps and close out on Friday evening.

Today we will try to figure out what is more correct - to try to close all positions by the weekend or not to pay attention to the weekend.

Tools and testing procedure

Tools and testing procedure — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend?

First of all, in order to test various exit options, I wrote an EA. It is very simple - it opens a trade at the start of Friday, and closes it, depending on the settings, either at 23:00 on Friday or at the start of Monday. Buy trades are made in even months of the year, sell trades in odd months. I decided to provide the following testing options:

  1. All trades are closed on Friday at 23:00;
  2. All trades are closed on Monday at the market open;
  3. On Friday at 23:00 only profitable trades are closed, all the others are closed on Monday at the open.

This trading system, of course, cannot produce a positive result, but we do not need that. What matters is looking at the results in comparison with each other. I will call this simple system the "Basic" one.

Nevertheless, one trading system will not give us reliability, especially one this simple. It is quite possible that its rules happen to suit a specific closing method. Therefore it makes sense to look at one more system and, preferably, a genuinely working one. For this, I added rules for closing all trades on Friday at 23:00 to a successfully working EA. Separately, I decided to test the option with closing only losing trades on Friday and only profitable ones. From now on I will call this system the "Working" one.

Testing results

Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend?

Below I will present to you the results of all tests of the basic system and begin with closing on Friday:

Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 2
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 3
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 4
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 5
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 6
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 7
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 8
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 9
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 10
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 11
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 12
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 13
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 14
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 15
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 16
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 17
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 18
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 19
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 20
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 21
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 22
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 23
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 24
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 25
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 26
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 27
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 28

Next come the results of the basic system with closing on Monday:

Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 29
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 30
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 31
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 32
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 33
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 34
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 35
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 36
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 37
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 38
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 39
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 40
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 41
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 42
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 43
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 44
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 45
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 46
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 47
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 48
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 49
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 50
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 51
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 52
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 53
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 54
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 55

And finally, the results of the basic system with profitable positions closed on Friday at 23:00 and the rest at the start of Monday:

Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 56
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 57
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 58
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 59
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 60
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 61
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 62
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 63
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 64
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 65
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 66
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 67
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 68
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 69
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 70
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 71
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 72
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 73
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 74
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 75
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 76
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 77
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 78
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 79
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 80
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 81

Backtest report showing a declining balance curve and a net loss of 4,116.64 across 977 tradesFor convenience in analyzing the data, I put all the results obtained into a combined table:

Color-coded table compares profit, drawdown and profit factor for forex trades closed Friday, Monday or when profitableFrom the table we can see that closing all trades on Friday is the worst option. The best one is closing only profitable trades on Friday while carrying losing ones over the weekend. Nevertheless, individual currency pairs produce better results when all positions are carried over to Monday.

As you can see, none of the options has an unambiguous advantage. Perhaps the test results of a real EA will be able to clarify the situation, and we will be able to determine the advantage of one of the methods.

Below is a set of tests of the working system without interference:

Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 82
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 83
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 84
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 85
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 86
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 87
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 88
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 89
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 90
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 91

Trading strategy backtest showing a rising balance curve over 200 trades, net profit of 1,840.22 and 5.50% drawdownNext come the tests of the system with all trades closed on Friday:

Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 92
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 93
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 94
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 95
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 96
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 97
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 98
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 99
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 100
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 101

Backtest report for closing all trades on Friday, showing a balance curve and 102.40 net profit across 196 tradesNext come the tests of the system with profitable trades closed on Friday:

Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 102
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 103
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 104
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 105
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 106
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 107
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 108
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 109
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 110
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 111

Backtest results for closing profitable trades on Friday, with a rising balance curve and 7.35% maximum drawdownNext come the tests of the system with losing trades closed on Friday:

Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 112
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 113
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 114
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 115
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 116
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 117
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 118
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 119
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 120
Testing results — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend, illustration 121

Backtest report for closing losing trades on Friday, showing 200 trades, 1,004.22 net profit and a rising balance curveAnd for convenience in analyzing the results, I put all the data into a single table:

Color-coded table comparing forex profit, drawdown and profit factor across four weekend trade management strategiesJudging by the table, closing all trades on Friday again turned out to be the worst option. Next comes closing losing trades on Friday, a little better is closing profitable trades on Friday. The best figures belong to the system without interfering with the trading rules.

Conclusions

Conclusions — Should You Leave Trades Open Over the Weekend?

As you can see, the system without interfering with the position-closing rules showed the best results. That is why you need to modify the rules of your TS very carefully and not put them into use without thorough testing.

In both systems, fully closing all trades on Friday evening showed the worst results. This suggests that such an approach to managing open positions still does not justify itself and that there is no need to be afraid of gaps. At the same time, it is quite possible that more sophisticated rules for closing positions on Friday can still improve the system. For example, you can try closing on Friday only those profitable trades that have already been in the market for more than a week (or some other period).

So, the desire to get rid of positions by Friday evening turned out to be yet another trader phobia, not supported by facts in any way. Before applying one or another popular rule for opening, modifying, or closing a position, it is simply necessary to thoroughly test its effect on the final result of your system on historical data.

And, of course, you should never blindly believe everything that is written somewhere, no matter how authoritative the source may seem. Develop in yourself the habit of thinking critically and practice the scientific approach. This, of course, will not automatically bring you a lot of money, but it will save you from a mass of delusions and save the time that you lose wandering along winding and false paths on the way to profitable trading.

Sincerely, Dmitry aka Silentspec TradeLikeaPro.ru

InstaForex